Why would anyone think that? At worst they might think of our troops as human, which is a far cry better than what they're portrayed as now; maybe we wouldn't be so eager to let Washington send them meaninglessly off to the slaughter in that case.
It's more likely people will think less of those who stigmatize the mental health industry after all, for believing that steaming plate of crap Tom Cruise has been serving up.
You've never met a midwestern redneck, have you Ken?
Sounds like an "If I close my eyes, maybe it will go away" reaction. Yes, it's their business on an individual level, but denial of the problem as a whole is even more unhealthy.
Sounds more like HIPPA. A person's medical history is
their business, soldier or civilian.
Huh? How is the image that they're human with human frailties distorted? Painting a false picture of them as superhuman automotons is the true distortion.
But they almost have to be, don't they? In order to gain our trust and keep it? Showing any sign of weakness could cost you your life. Case in point, a Kirkwood, MO officer was dealing with a case of fireworks in St. Louis county near the 4th of July (where fireworks are prohibited in St. Louis county at all times of the year). Apparently this officer had a bad reputation with the black community in that area and a young man--pretty much still a boy shot him. I can't confirm that he was actually harrassing the black community or not, but he showed weakness in that moment and now he's gone.
That's what we're getting either way, and as scary as the truth is, is obstinate denial preferable?
I can't answer that question because I could argue both sides.
If that firefighter were declared fit for duty by competent evaluators, I don't see why you'd have to worry.
Your post seems to be carrying (possibly unintentionally) the undercurrent that there is no place in society for our traumatized firefighters, soldiers, etc, many of whom have done so much for us. Sad.
Actually, I'm not trying to. I was asking HC if he could see what I meant by that quote, which is a direct quote from a family friend after watching an earlier episode of "Rescue Me". If he has these thoughts about firemen from a television show that is quite popular, then who is to say that others don't share the same view? And eventually don't you think that those people will turn their back on those who pledge to "serve and protect us". Furthermore, not to turn this into "nigger this, nigger that" but if racism can be passed down in a family, this form of profiling certainly can too.
---
Mediocrity at its most average.