Okay, judging time. My favourites are:
fuzzyman - The Pixel, who is only slightly harder to draw than The Amoeba.
TheElPaso - Captain Unobvious, who looks far more like a superhero than his more obvious alter ego.
skagg - Minuteman, though that entry may well have come from Captain Obvious...
Blew_Crabs - Dex Men. Lots of work went into that one... and I really want X-ray vision!
Drexle - Ubermench, bringing a level of intelelctualism to the proceedings. (I want to know, though - after spending all his time fighting monsters, in which issue does he himself become a monster?)
fuzzyman - X-Man. You deserve a special mention just for sifting through all the piles of gay porn, looking for source pics.
fuzzyman - Supersnuggles, mainly because the world doesn't have enough superpowered pets.
...but who gets the nod? I suppose the winner will have to be fuzzyman for the comhined coolness of all of his entries, though Blew_Crabs is a close second with Dex Men. Well done, fuzz.
---
This signature has performed an illegal operation and has been shut down.