You could sometimes use the amish character to represent a pilgrim, but you couldn't always use him, because not all of your comics are going to have a pilgrim in them unless you suddenly start making nothing but pilgrim comics from now on for some reason.
You could get a curse.
Like, biped, I just put a pilgrim curse on you. Now you can only make pilgrim comics. For one week. That includes contest comics.
This should be interesting. *gets beer and popcorn*