Important notice about the future of Stripcreator (Updated: May 2nd, 2023)

stripcreator forums
Jump to:

Stripcreator » Read My Damn Comics » Constructive Criticism Please :P

Author

Message

Nitefly
Stripcreator Newbie

Member Rated:

4-27-05 2:30pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


attitudechicka
is never bored.

Member Rated:

Presenting attitudechicka's thoughts on...

1. "The Truth": Good. There was too much dialogue, though. You lose your audience in the first panel because some of the dialogue is really useless to explaining your point (Case in point "It sucks.")

2. "The Reason to be": I don't normally like narration boxes, but they were surprisingly useful in making this comic humorful. Still not the funniest thing I've seen.

3. "The meaning of life": L-E-A-R-N-E-D. If that was some kind of joke, I missed it. Overall, depressing more than funny.

4. "The Phone": Again, depressing. Nothing special, and not funny.

5. "Geek Comic 1": Okay. Again, nothing special, and we already know that boys are zombies once they're gaming.

6. "Owned": Actually, worth the click. Future reference, you can only put 5 comics in one post. It was pretty good, best of the set. I'd use the height prop for the guy inside on the last panel, though.

Overall judgement: You have potential. Work it out.

---
Mediocrity at its most average.

4-27-05 3:17pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


andydougan
Film critic subordinaire

Member Rated:

"The Truth" is very good, but I'd cut down the dialogue in the third panel. I find it helps the timing if the last panel is succinct.

I'd actually say "Owned" is the worst of the lot. What's the joke, that goatse.cx is unpleasant to look at? Not exactly revelatory.

But in your defence: dictionary.reference.com/search?q=learnt

4-27-05 3:47pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


BigFrank105
Obsessive Comic Disorder

Member Rated:

I think he's a cross between Niteowl and Kajun Firefly (get it? nyuck nyuck nyuck)

In any case, I think he's good.

4-27-05 4:16pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


Inflatable_Man
Heart stopper. Hip hopper. Pill popper.

Member Rated:

I thought... *puffs on bubble pipe*... it was better than sex...

---
Destroying my reputation one post at a time.

4-27-05 5:51pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


not_Scyess
not laughing with you

Member Rated:

"Owned" is too old a joke to be funny anymore, and I thought "The Truth" had potential but didn't make it. The rest were fucking hilarious, though... especially "Reason to Be".

---
peddling the funny around since 09/24/2002

4-27-05 8:50pm (new)
quote : comics : pm : info


attitudechicka
is never bored.

Member Rated:

quote:

But in your defence: dictionary.reference.com/search?q=learnt

Oh god no.

---
Mediocrity at its most average.

4-28-05 9:26am (new)
quote : comics : pm : info

Stripcreator » Read My Damn Comics » Constructive Criticism Please :P


reload page with comics

Jump to:

Post A Reply


stripcreator
Make a comic
Your comics
Log in
Create account
Forums
Help
comics
Random Comic
Comic Contests
Sets
All Comics
Search
featuring
diesel sweeties
jerkcity
exploding dog
goats
ko fight club
penny arcade
chopping block
also
Brad Sucks